|
2002: The 3 best turntables, and
there is little argument about it here in the U.S. (an amazing thing,
consensus amongst audiophiles! :-) are the Rockport Sirius III, the Walker
Proscenium Gold, and the SME 30/2. All three are easy to use AFTER they
are setup (only the SME is easy to setup) - which is a crucial requirement
for many as they do not want to have to fuss with the thing every time an
album is played.
2006 Well, that was then and this is now.
There is much more confusion in the turntable world these days. The new
Continuum at $90K and the Blue Pearl at $80K has hit our shores. Rockport
is in the process of making a new 'statement' turntable. There has been a
flood of $29K turntables into the market, many of very high quality:
Brinkmann, Red Point, Immedia, Grand Prix Audio, etc. Just how much better
are the $70K+ turntables?
|

  |
Rockport Technologies
-
Using an air-bearing tonearm
and platter, the Rockport Sirius III ($70K) is considered the best
turntable ever built. There is also a Sirius II (at about $30K, but it is
the tiniest bit on the cool side) and the Capella (about $25K, but hasn't
been built in a few years now). Andy Payor, the builder, is now focusing
on making his speakers and no longer makes turntables anymore - but these
are still considered the high-bar and are sometimes, infrequently
available on the used market.
These turntables use air suspension for the platter and linear-tracking
tonearm. The price includes the tonearm. The Sirius III got a rave review
from Mike Fremer at Stereophile (see website) and is in general considered
the best turntable currently available. But it is a close race...
| Prices |
$20,000 - $72,000 |
| Pictured |
Sirius III, Sirius III,
and Capella II |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Air |
| Tonearm suspension |
Air |
| Tonearm tracking |
Linear (parallel) |
| Tonearms supported |
|
| Record clamp |
Vacuum |
| Drive |
Belt, Direct drive |
| Platter |
|
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
 |
Continuum
-
| Prices |
$90,000 |
| Pictured |
|
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
None |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
Tangential |
| Tonearms supported |
1 |
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Direct drive |
| Platter |
|
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
 |
Blue Pearl
-
| Prices |
$80,000 |
| Pictured |
|
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
None |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
Tangential |
| Tonearms supported |
1 |
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Belt
drive |
| Platter |
|
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
Yes |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |

 |
Walker Audio
-
Pictured: Proscenium Gold Signature TurntableThis is the Walker Proscenium Gold ($25K or
so, depending on options). This turntable also uses air suspension for the
platter and linear-tracking tonearm. This turntable got a rave review from
Jonanthan Valin at TAS who continues to be enamored with this 'table.
Everybody who owns this turntable absolutely loves it and the builder,
Lloyd Walker, continually works on improving the table and will setup your
turntables in person (for a fee which the dealer should pay). Price
includes the tonearm.
| Prices |
$35,000 - $40,000 |
| Pictured |
Proscenium Gold
Signature Turntable |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Air |
| Tonearm suspension |
Air |
| Tonearm tracking |
Linear |
| Tonearms supported |
Walker only |
| Record clamp |
Tightenable clamp |
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
Lead |
| Weight |
245 lbs |
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
Yes |
|
| |
|
Reviewers |
Reviews |
|
Absolute Sound
December/January 2003 |
(Proscenium Gold Signature Turntable) |
Audio Asylum
December 2001 |
(Proscenium Gold Signature Turntable) |
Audio Asylum
December 2002 |
(Proscenium Gold Signature Turntable) |
|
|
|
 |

 |
Brinkmann
-
| Prices |
$6,000 - $20,000 |
| Pictured |
Balance |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
Tangential |
| Tonearms supported |
Brinkmann, others... |
| Record clamp |
Screw on |
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
Glass |
| Weight |
40 lbs. |
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
Yes |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |


 |
Transrotor
-
| Prices |
$2,000 - $70,000 |
| Pictured |
Gravita, Tourbillon
Gold, Leonardo 25/40 |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
|
| Tonearms supported |
Graham 2.2, others... |
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
Acrylic |
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
2 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |


 |
V.Y.G.E.R
-
This turntable is hand-built in Italy and
was imported and distributed by
Acoustic Drreams.
| Prices |
$70,000 |
| Pictured |
Indian Signature,
Indian, Atlantis |
| Platform suspension |
Optional |
| Platter suspension |
Air |
| Tonearm suspension |
Air |
| Tonearm tracking |
Linear |
| Tonearms supported |
|
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
|
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
Yes |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |

 |
SpJ by Judy Spotheim
-
The turntable is distributed by Cardas in
the U.S. It has a reputation as being very lively and a little forward in
the upper midrange, perhaps over-emphasizing defects in LPs (like pops and
clicks).
| Prices |
$16,500 (with tonearm) -
$19,500 (with tonearm) (2000) |
| Pictured |
La Luce, La Luce CS
Centoventi |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
|
| Tonearms supported |
Graham 2.2, others... |
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
Acrylic with embedded
columns of metal |
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
Yes |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |

 |
SME
-
The SME 30/2 - ($25K + tonearm) is one of
the best, popular high-end turntables. This is a conventional turntable
except that it has a nice built in suspension. SME is manufactured in
England by a company (most of the other best tables are hand-built). SME
is a subsidiary of a larger company that manufactures parts for aircraft
instruments and business machines. SME makes 2 other turntables which have
a reputation for being a little on the cool side and built like tanks (and
perhaps somewhat boring looking). Mike Fremer (Stereophile) gave this
table a rave review (using a Graham 2.2 tonearm, not the SME tonearm) in
the February 2003 Stereophile - and wrote that this table may
be comparable with the Rockport Sirius III.
| Prices |
$6,000 (SME 10 with
tonearm) - $25000 (SME 30/2 without tonearm) |
| Pictured |
SME 30/2A (with matching
SME Series V tonearm), SME 10 |
| Platform suspension |
Yes |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
No |
| Tonearm tracking |
|
| Tonearms supported |
Graham 2.2, others... |
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Direct |
| Platter |
|
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |

 |
Simon Yorke
-
This turntable was Michael Fremer (Stereophile)'s
reference turntable until 2003 when he switched to the SME 30/2.
| Prices |
$15,000 |
| Pictured |
Series 7 |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
|
| Tonearm tracking |
|
| Tonearms supported |
Simon Yorke |
| Record clamp |
None |
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
|
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
Reviewers |
Reviews |
|
Hi-Fi News and Record Review April 1998 |
Series 7 |
|
Stereophile
June 1998 |
Series 7 |
|
|
|
 |

 |
Clearaudio
-
This is one of the most popular selling
turntables - and one of the best looking. The use of 3 motors and a solid
acrylic platter contribute to some sonic degradation according to some.
| Prices |
$17,500 - $100,000 |
| Pictured |
Master Reference (with
TQ 1 parallel tracking tonearm) |
| Platform suspension |
None |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
|
| Tonearm tracking |
Linear (parallel) |
| Tonearms supported |
Graham 2.2, others... |
| Record clamp |
None |
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
Acrylic |
| Weight |
|
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
3 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |
|
|
Basis
-
This table, along with the SME and VPI, is
one of the few tables that offers built-in suspension. It is also one of
the few, along with the Rockport, that offers a vacuum record clamp (to
hold the LP down).
| Prices |
$1,200 - $10,600 |
| Pictured |
Debut Mk. V (previously
Gold Standrd), 1400 |
| Platform suspension |
Optional |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
|
| Tonearms supported |
Basis Vector, Graham
2.2, others... |
| Record clamp |
Vacuum optional (Debut) |
| Drive |
Direct |
| Platter |
Acrylic, composite |
| Weight |
120 lbs |
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
No |
|
| |
|
Reviewers |
Reviews |
|
Stereophile
Vol.23 No.1, January 2000 |
Debut Gold |
|
|
|
 |
 |
VPI -
| Prices |
$1,200 - $10,600 |
| Pictured |
TNT Mk. V |
| Platform suspension |
Optional |
| Platter suspension |
Bearing |
| Tonearm suspension |
None |
| Tonearm tracking |
|
| Tonearms supported |
TNT Mk. V |
| Record clamp |
|
| Drive |
Belt |
| Platter |
aluminum and lead-filled
acrylic |
| Weight |
120 lbs |
| Maximum number of
tonearms |
1 |
| Out-board motor |
Yes |
|
| |
|
|
|
 |